The New York and Chicago Experience
Pick Your Pie!
New York Style
A true handheld culinary experience
A foldable yet crispy thin crust pizza that isboth soft and slightly brown with asalty cheese and smooth, sweet red sauce.
Chicago Style
a fork and knife affair
A classic deep dish pie with creamy cheese on the bottomand fresh chunky tomato sauce on the topcooked with a butter crust and caramelized cheese.
New York Style
A true handheld culinary experience
A foldable yet crispy thin crust pizza that is both soft and slightly brown with a salty cheese and smooth, sweet red sauce.
Chicago Style
a fork and knife affair
A classic deep dish pie with creamy cheese on the bottom and fresh chunky tomato sauce on the top cooked with a butter crust and caramelized cheese.
THE STORY OF TWO CITIES PIZZA
The New York and Chicago Experience began with two lifelong best friends and two cities, each city with its own rich pizza tradition. Sean and Zach found themselves in the thick of the great pizza debate: New York thin crust versus Chicago deep dish. From there they endeavored to create a place where people could experience both styles on the same table. It all started within the walls of the historic City Hall building in Mason, Ohio…
read the complete story
THE LATEST FROM INSTAGRAM
Join the Waitlist
While we do not take reservations, we highly recommend joining the waitlist before you arrive.
Join the waitlistOrder Online
Dine In, Carry Out or Delivery
Craving delicious, hot pizza? Order online for a fast, easy, and hassle-free experience! Browse our menu, customize your perfect pie, and have it ready for pickup or delivered straight to your door. Fresh ingredients, bold flavors — just a few clicks away!
Order NowLet Us Cater Your Party
24 hour notice is required for all catering orders. Click the button below to start your catering request.
Order Now